Home

- | +

Oneshot | Blackballed

  • 1st Jun, 2009 at 8:41 PM
Regulus forehead
Title: Blackballed
Challenge: Beware, The Ides of March at [info]fandomfusion.
Prompt: (6) Nymph and (65) He’s got to make his own mistakes/And learn to mend the mess he makes/He’s old enough to know what’s right/But young enough not to choose it - 'New World Man' by Rush
Characters/Year: Regulus and Sirius Black, 1976
Rating: PG13 for swearing
Word Count: ~ 3000
Summary: Regulus sees Sirius' step outside family lines as personal rejection. Will Regulus take that step himself? Or was his brother's choice less visionary and more opportunistic? Having lost contact over the summer holiday, Sirius and Regulus meet-up for the first time since the familial disownment.
A/N: This story has been stored in my memory and in bits on my hard drive for a while, and [info]fandomfusion's genfic and art challenge was a chance for it to have an official lj home. It was meant to be enjoyed, and I hope that happens if you read. It's unbeta'd, so politely point out spotted errors.



____

I’ve lost track of how long I’ve been lying here. Been here flat on my back, concentrating on the scent of my fag to cut out the smell of scattered leaves decaying into the soil. If the autumn weather weren’t so warm, heating up the ground and spoiling the vegetation, it might not be as sour down here as it is.

But I like it anyway. Hogsmeade Saturdays are a chance at freedom, a bit of space for myself.

I tuck my forearm under my head as a pillow and the breeze laps my face, and I consider how useless eyelids are against the sun. Closed, everything turns into a pinky shade of yellow—it makes things dim, but not dark—and I wonder if this haze is what the first stage of blindness is like, like closing my eyes and facing the sun.

The wiry grass pricks my calves through my trousers and the din of insects and birds calms me. Then I hear it, my older brother’s bloody typical entrance scheme—bang and thrash on the way in—and it makes me catch my breath after having peacefully settled in.

A drag off my cigarette flattens my spiked nerves, and suddenly I feel the lump of my cufflink pressing into the back of my head.

“You’ve no stealth, Sirius.” I call out.

The banging continues. “What are you on about, little nipper?”

Piss off with the little nipper. “Do you have to walk so loud?”

“Why, yes. Yes, I do.”

He sounds as if he’s stomping on parchment as he marches towards me through the leaves, and I turn my head in his direction and squint at him through half-open lids. He’s twirling a tan sack in one hand and swatting and slicing low hanging branches with a cane in the other. No, it’s a stick. A very big, straight stick.

I realign my head on my forearm. “You don’t know the first thing about stealth, if you insist on making such racket.”

“Perhaps I do, perhaps I do not.” From his tone of voice, I can tell he’s enjoying annoying me, formulating a fresh confrontation to divert attention from his being late. “Or perhaps you’ve got it backwards, little nipper.”

“Yeah? How so?”

He’s strolled up to my face now, and I’m eyelevel to his boots. I cut them a glance. They’re bruised, cracked black leather with white untied laces—Doc Martens, he’s said. Immediately I think of my neat shirt cuffs hidden under my head, folded that precise way I like, and already I worry I’m too tidy for my brother’s new tastes, and I’m half-sick he’ll pick a fight over my family crest cufflinks if he sees. Sirius can punch someone’s lights out without any trouble, although he’s never turned right nasty on me.

“So come on then,” I ask. “How’ve I got it backwards?”

“Perhaps I’ve been keeping myself secret, hiding here in these weeds, and you weren’t clever enough to spot me, and I caught you by surprise. And in that case, if you claim that I, Sirius Black, do not know the first thing about stealth,” he sighs, then continues, “well, it means you’ve got the bloody wrong end of the stick.”

Sirius prods his stick at my chest as he speaks, and it’s a sharp little tap, so I lean up onto my elbows, pushing it away me, and he backs off.

I frown at him. “Er . . . you didn’t exactly catch me by surprise.”

“Either way.” Sirius chucks the stick into the brush and it clatters out of sight. “One thing is obvious.”

“What?”

“I did catch you napping.”

He’s impossible to contradict. “You did, yes.” I didn’t manage to sound satisfactorily upset, so I add, “Waiting on someone does become dull after a bit.”

“Don’t blame me that you hung around waiting.”

Waiting around all afternoon for Sirius doesn’t bother me in the slightest, but that’s exactly what he’s expecting, so I don’t have to say it. He’s aware I’m a loner, but it also infuriates him to know I’ll wander around alone, hanging around for him.

I’m pathetic, yet it always seems worth it after he arrives.

Drawing my legs and torso together, I instinctively begin to stand, but Sirius shakes his head and drops into the grass next to me. He stretches out his legs, cupping his hands between his thighs and curls his fingers under his crotch and hunches. He knocks his boots together, then crosses his ankles. This is his, I’m sorry, posture. The one taken when he hopes for understanding.

“What were you doing?” I ask, although I’m certain he won't tell.

“Mind your own business.”

Of course. There’s no telling how long his inattention might go on, and I watch him for a moment, having no idea what to say that he may find relevant enough to respond to.

“I know, I’m late,” he says, trying to not please me too much with a full apology. “We were playing Frisbee.”

“What’s that?”

“It’s this Muggle game, it's played by tossing a disc through the air at your teammate to catch, keeping it away from your opponent.”

He turns towards me for the first time since sitting with me in the sun. He’s gleaming with sweat and his clothes look slept in and his t-shirt is wet under his arms.

“James is bloody fucking brilliant at snatching—” He presses his lips into a thin line, then ducks away as if he were struck, meaning disappointment has settled into my face and he won’t look at it.

I want to throw James back in his face, but that would only irritate him further, and he’d leave. I haven’t seen him on his own since end of last term, and I was anxious for meeting up. He can't go—not yet.

“Ah, is . . . is Frisbee a bit like Quidditch?” Childish want kicks in my head, hoping that if I keep asking questions, he’ll answer, Yes, it’s exactly like Quidditch, and I’ve come to ask you to play with us. “Because it sounds like Quidditch,” I stammer. “Sort of.”

“No, it’s not like Quidditch. Frisbee’s a bit boring for me, actually.” He quickly decides not to go on about their game. “Look, today slipped through my fingers, and I’m sorry for making a late show.”

“Two hours late.” I barely say it.

“Christ. Really?”

I nod. It doesn’t matter if I confirm the length of my wait or not. Between the truth and what Sirius likes to think is the truth lies a canyon, and he manages to avoid being pushed into it by asking questions which sound imploring, but are too worthless to answer. It’s his way of implying he’ll go a mile for you when, really, he won’t give up an inch.

“Come out of it, little nipper. Don’t sulk,” he laughs, not for me, but to soften his own hardening mood. “I’ll stay the rest of the afternoon.”

Sirius angles his face at me with an expression I think is meant to make me feel more sorry for him for being late than for my own waiting.

“Can we just move on from here?” he asks.

“Sure.” I stare at the long line of ash hanging from my still burning fag, and then thoroughly snuff it on the grass.

Sirius plucks one from the case he’s dug out of his jeans, and he gestures at me with it. I shake my head, and as I watch him light up, I see it for the first time.

“What’s on your face?” I flick the skin above my upper lip.

“Oh, the moustache?”

“You’re not shaving?”

“I think that’s rather the point when growing a moustache.”

“Why are you doing that?” Now that he’s tucked his hair behind his ear, I notice a gastly long trail of black hair curving from his ear to his sharp jaw. “And sideburns, too?”

“What difference does it make why I’m doing it. I’m doing it simply because I can now I’ve gotten out of that sodding place you still live at.” He looks at me unapologetically.

I give him a long, searching look, wondering if he wants me to agree with him that home is a rubbish pile and say something contrite for remaining there after he left. But then he grins because he knows I’m fourteen years old and too young to choose to do otherwise, even if I know I ought to.

“I think it makes me look a bit like Jimmy Page. He’s wearing a moustache this year,” Sirius adds.

“I—I don’t know who that is.”

“Of course you don’t.” He rolls his eyes. “It makes me look more mature, then. Older.”

“Old?”

“No, not sodding old. Older.”

“But your whiskers are like bits of dirt on your face.” I wave my head across my mouth. “Or like the black firecracks in the porcelain Mummy received from Chin—”

Sirius cuts his eyes sharply at mine—can’t talk about that. Porcelain’s all right, but by saying Mother, I’ve sucked the small amount of joy straight from the moment.

Neither of us seems certain what is the safest next thing to say, and I say nothing.

Sirius pats the side of his face, then strokes his upper lip. “Well, it’s got a ways to go before its full effect can be appreciated.”

His tone makes it plain we’ve quit the topic of moustaches, too, and I realise we’ve now quickly gone wrong with both Frisbee and facial hair, and we’re a lifetime away from knowing anything about one another any more.

“Why do you want to pretend to be older, anyway?” I ask quietly.

“Bollocks, Regulus, I’m not pretending to be older. You know what I mean.”

I’m unsure I do, but I don’t want him to notice this, and then say he understands because I’ve never seen the point of understanding with him. It never changes anything, and I silently sit next to him, knowing the worst of it is that this eternal bond between us won’t break anytime soon.

Sirius pushes a cool, grey metal tin into my hand. “Oh, here, I’ve got you this.”

“What is it?”

“It’s from Honeydukes. I mean, you still like them, don’t you? They're Juicy Root Black Balls.”

He giggles like a ten year old when he says the words, and I smile a little, reading the label as daylight streaks brightly across the metal. It lies in my hands, making the uncomfortable quiet slightly easier to bear. “Thank you.”

“You don’t have to say that. I felt like doing it. I wanted to.” He huffs out a breath with something approaching relief.

“Thanks, though. Really.”

Sirius flushes mildly and begins a discontented frown. “You’re not, you know, making up for my faults around home, are you?”

I tense, slightly bewildered by his question. “No. I’m . . . . What do you mean?”

“You know what I mean.”

“No. I don’t. And if I suspect what you do mean, there isn’t any of that going on.”

“You’re sure?”

“Yes.” A sinking feeling settles in my limbs as the chance for sitting here in contented brotherly friendship quickly passes.

“You’d tell me if there were, right?”

“Would I tell you? Tell you? Fuck it. How? How would I tell you, Sirius?”

Sirius narrows his eyes for an instant, puzzled by my reaction.

“I’ve written you precisely seventeen times and received one reply. One. Did you even bother to read my Owls?”

“I—I—”

“No. Of course you didn’t. But I know the Owls I sent arrived because in the one reply I did get from you, you said . . . let’s see . . . what did you say? Ah, you said, I don’t see the point in writing. But I did still write. I wrote every bloody week.”

From the reproachful look he's shooting me, I know I’m pouncing on him now, and I hesitate momentarily, uncertain if I ought to continue, but I’m caught by all the disappointment I ended up with after he left for James, showing me I no longer suited him.

“Shall we perform the arithmetic, Sirius? It’s what you hate about me isn’t it, that I reason everything?"

“That’s unfair, Regulus. How could I hate you?”

“There’re approximately three months in the holiday. Four weeks in a month. Three months is twelve weeks. Oh, my, what a bloody wanker am I, because I wrote seventeen letters. I wrote twice a week for starters, with no reply from you, and then continued even after you replied that couldn’t see a point replying.”

“I was trying—”

“And I was fucking concerned enough to hire public Owls from the MOMpost to elimiate the ravens since they’d be a touch too much like sending you a souvenir from home.”

“Are you finished?”

“You’ve no idea how wonderfully brilliant clear-cut inaccessibility from your own brother can be. Or were you just maintaining consistency? Have it all your way. Clean break from the family, and all that.”

“You know perfectly well it wasn’t entirely my choice. My god who chooses this kind of thing? I didn’t have a bloody choice by the time I left home. It’s the way things turned out.”

“You bloody dumped me and Mummy and Father so you could—”

“I didn’t dump you!”

“So you could—”

“What? So I could what? Be with James?”

I immediately realise that I am about to cry and don’t answer. I drop my head, pry open the canister with fumbling fingers, and start forcing chewy sweet balls into my mouth.

"So I could what? Regulus?"

I shiver and continue to stuff the sweets. He reaches for the tin, but I press it protectively against my chest.

“Don’t do that.” He sounds worried. “You’ll vomit.” And tender. “Please stop.”

My eyes are squeezed shut so tightly that they sting, and know when they open they’ll be pink.

“You think she would have let you at my letters? Do you? That if they managed to somehow reach you, she would have allowed you to have them?”

I can’t speak because I’m pushing down my throat the mouthful of licorique that’s become mashed and greasy on my tongue and against my cheeks.

“Well, do you?” he demands.

Sirius wants me to answer, but my lips are wet, and I try to lick away the saliva on the sides of my mouth as I shake my head. “You didn’t read my posts. Mummy wouldn't've seen yours, if you had read mine.”

“What?”

I hear feigned surprise in his voice, and now I’m certain he dismissed my posts entirely.

“I know you didn’t read them, Sirius.”

“Why do you say that? Of course I did.” He tries again, flattening his words this time to sound nonchalant.

“No, you didn’t.” I correct him. “I included a charm for you, an encryption charm, and I wrote you the code in the first few letters. If you used the charm, the messages would be invisibly sent from you to me at a common pickup box at a MOMP location, then I’d get a signal at Grimmauld that post from you had arrived. I wrote the charm it this summer. I picked it up from Father’s charmineering guides.”

“How would you have got out of the house to get to the MOMP office?”

“I picked one near Barty Crouch’s home—”

“Oh, for fuck sakes, Regulus.” He angrily interrupts. “What are you doing spending time with that little dickhead?”

I feel that familiar rawness at the back of my thoughts, the one Sirius always opens when he tries to protect me with his half-measures. “I picked the office near Barty’s because I’m permitted to go to his home without being questioned.” I shrug and clutch the tin. “And we get along.”

“Barty Crouch, Jr is seven kinds of wanker. I don’t like him, and you stay the fuck away from him. Understand me?”

“You don’t like him?”

“No, and neither should you.”

“And you’re ordering me to keep away from him?” I laugh.

“Yeah, I guess I am. His father works at the Ministry with James’ father, and James tells me—”

“James tells you. James tells you. This is precisely the bollocks with you I’m talking about, Sirius!”

“What?”

“Are you making me say it?” Will he make me say that he chose James over me?

“Making you say what?”

“That you . . . you . . . you—”

“Oi! Regulus, Christ!”

My head's spinning as my stomach twists up and splashes out of me, and for an instant I’m removed from where I am or what I’m doing until I feel Sirius rubbing his hand between my shoulder blades because he’s always done that to calm me.

And then I see it, there on the grubby grass and shriveled leaves, are my wasted, partially chewed Black Balls.

____

Comments

( 29 players — Play the language game )
[info]hereticalvision wrote:
2nd Jun, 2009 09:48 (UTC)
Interesting. Regulus just doesn't get enough love IMO so always good to see things from his perspective and your Sirius is so canon - all self-obsessed and unable to tell when he's hurting someone who loves him. Nice work.
[info]duck_or_rabbit wrote:
2nd Jun, 2009 13:43 (UTC)
Ah, gosh, thanks! I'm glad that Sirius is IC, and Regulus, well, we don't know for sure, do we? The Black Boys are the reason I write fanfiction, and I agree that Regulus ought to be explored, and I'm pleased you found this incarnation of him interesting.

Thank you so much for the nice comments, and thank YOU for participating in the challenge, :D.
[info]chococoffeekiss wrote:
2nd Jun, 2009 16:20 (UTC)
YAY! I do so love your Sirius and Regulus. :D
Particularly liked how you contrasted their appearance, how Regulus is so tidy and Sirius wants to look like Jimmy Page.

The awkward kind of tension between them is just perfect!

You're the best, love!

[info]duck_or_rabbit wrote:
3rd Jun, 2009 02:56 (UTC)
Oh, thank you so much for the review! (Were you searching for safety and comfort while the cake makers badgered you about icing?)

LOL, I was telling [info]werewolfsfan that Sirius' Jimmy Page impersonation may have been self-obsessed and short lived, but he may have been living on clothing rations at this point and decided to try out a disheveled face, too. I'm pleased the contrasting appearances helped illuminated them in this, :D.

I'm also pleased the tension translated in first person POV because I was going for awkward, not crazy, lol.

No, you're the best!

Thank you for taking time out for me as your matrimonial deadline approaches!!
[info]cicatrix_alba wrote:
2nd Jun, 2009 19:54 (UTC)
Awkwardness and Tension
Indeed. This:

'Of course. There’s no telling how long his inattention might go on, and I watch him for a moment, having no idea what to say that he may find relevant enough to respond to.'

and this:

'It’s his way of implying he’ll go a mile for you, when, really, he won’t give up an inch.'

...were so good they hurt. Tell me, do I have *everything* wrong, or just most of it? Because I highly suspect that JKR is the fictional character, and that all the HP books and most of the fanfic are, in fact, detailed diaries, rather like the Mass Observation Project, and thus completely real.

You *are* Sirius. Come on, admit it.

[info]cicatrix_alba wrote:
2nd Jun, 2009 20:38 (UTC)
Re: Awkwardness and Tension
Fucking fuck. Total brain failure. I re-read that, and realised that the stick had 2 shitty ends, not one.

I am a stupid bastard. All I meant to say was that your grasp of Sirius is the best imaginable, not that his shortcomings are yours. Jesus *God*. Please just blame it on being a Tuesday (head-shrinking day).

Mea culpa, mea culpa, mea maxima culpa.
[info]duck_or_rabbit wrote:
2nd Jun, 2009 20:43 (UTC)
Re: Awkwardness and Tension
All I meant to say was that your grasp of Sirius is the best imaginable, not that his shortcomings are yours.

If I were Sirius, my darling, I would be a better person than I am. His positive attributes far outweigh his errant ways.

♥ ♥ ♥

And I was chuffed that you think I'm Sirius. You had me massively grinning.

I think we need some porn next, yeah?

Edited at 2009-06-02 20:43 (UTC)
[info]cicatrix_alba wrote:
2nd Jun, 2009 20:46 (UTC)
Re: Awkwardness and Tension
Yes please...
[info]cicatrix_alba wrote:
2nd Jun, 2009 21:35 (UTC)
Re: Yes please...
'Something like that, yes ;) 'Just the ticket.

*bites lip and smirks*
[info]duck_or_rabbit wrote:
2nd Jun, 2009 23:29 (UTC)
Thank you a million!
It always makes me squee to see text quoted because it means ::something:: I wrote was worth reading, and, if I'm honest, I like that bit about Sirius not budging an inch, too.

There's another 3K words to this, but because it wasn't edited when I finished this 'story', and I know many readers prefer to not read first person POV, I chose to wrap up their interaction at this point. Where I'm going with this is there's a solid reason Sirius didn't respond to Regulus' owls; he's not being massively dickish.

The idea that fandom generated JRK is brilliant, lol! I love how your mind operates.

Yours truly,
::Sirius::

Edited at 2009-06-02 23:30 (UTC)
[info]cicatrix_alba wrote:
3rd Jun, 2009 06:50 (UTC)
Re: Thank you a million!
Why are damaged goods always the best ones in the shop?

If there is more to this fic then you *know*, you absolutely *know* what I'm going to say next. Privately or publically...

I love 1st person if it's Black enough *coughs*
[info]duck_or_rabbit wrote:
3rd Jun, 2009 20:14 (UTC)
Re: Thank you a million!
Aw, you're too kind! And I'd still write even if no one were reading, but I absolutely adore your insights you leave in comments about these characters, and that's just so rewarding for writer to receive, thank you, ♥.
[info]werewolfsfan wrote:
3rd Jun, 2009 02:05 (UTC)
Obviously, I'm perpetually drawn to the broken boys.
Oh baby! I’m glad that Sirius tried to keep some kind of a relationship with his brother but they’re already so dysfunctional that I would ache for them even without knowing the looming tragedy.

I want to throw James back in his face, but that would only irritate him further, and he’d leave. I haven’t seen him on his own since end of last term, and I was anxious for meeting up. He can't go—not yet.

“Ah, is . . . is Frisbee a bit like Quidditch?” Childish want kicks in my head, hoping that if I keep asking questions, he’ll answer, Yes, it’s exactly like Quidditch, and I’ve come to ask you to play with us. “Because it sounds like Quidditch,” I stammer. “Sort of.”

Your writing style is so vivid that I could “see” the sunshine through my own eyelids and smell the decaying leaves but here is something that I can’t “see.”

“What’s on your face?” I flick the skin above my upper lip.

“Oh, the moustache?”

“Why are you doing that?” Now that he’s tucked his hair behind his ear, I notice a gastly long trail of black hair curving from his ear to his sharp jaw. “And sideburns, too?”

Sirius pats the side of his face, then strokes his upper lip. “Well, it’s got a ways to go before its full effect can be appreciated.”

The discussion about the letters and the lengths that Reg had to go to to write to his own brother are chilling but totally fascinating. I adore detail and you’ve delivered in spades here. I will resist judging Sirius yet for not answering as I see your promising another tale about that but it’s difficult with this resonating across my heart:

I hesitate momentarily, uncertain if I ought to continue, but I’m caught by all the disappointment I ended up with after he left for James, showing me I no longer suited him.
[info]duck_or_rabbit wrote:
3rd Jun, 2009 02:38 (UTC)
Re: Obviously, I'm perpetually drawn to the broken boys.
LOL, what are you talking about? You can't see Sirius with a 'tache and chops, :D? I'm not sure if he'd do that for long, but I ultimately blame the 70s for materializing that idea, lol. And say that Sirius is coping with being on his own and wanted to mark the end of an era with facial hair. Silly boy.

Ah, what a tremendous review, thank you, :D. Like you say, tragedy looms for these brothers, and the misfortune for them both is their lack of brotherly influence as they strive to develop autonomy as older teenagers.

Your writing style is so vivid that I could “see” the sunshine through my own eyelids and smell the decaying leaves

Oh, well, my, that's encouraging! Many thanks for telling me, :D. Amidst Regulus' tenderheartedness, it felt important to also put him somewhere that wasn't mental, but in a place with surroundings and shape, and I'm glad the sensory imagery translated (which can be hard in first person if you don't want the narrator to transform into a crazy person talking to themselves).

I will resist judging Sirius yet for not answering as I see your promising another tale

I worry to that whatever Sirius may explain to Regulus will be empty words because Sirius drew a line and crossed it by leaving the family. No matter what his account, he and his brother will always be walking a cracked road.

Thank you so much for this; it's heartening to have you love the Black brothers a devotedly as you do! Certainly motivates me to write!




[info]train_lindz wrote:
3rd Jun, 2009 23:01 (UTC)
So glad to see this as a finished product and it is everything I expected it to be. Shouldn't be surprised, because your Regulus and Sirius are very distinct and wonderful.

I always really like the dialogue you have between them because they sound different and have their own voices, there is something familiar in their words and phrasing, no matter how far Sirius tries to escape the family.

I never thought so much about Regulus until I met you :)

[info]duck_or_rabbit wrote:
5th Jun, 2009 03:19 (UTC)
I never thought so much about Regulus until I met you :)

I've no idea why I find Regulus so diverting; my guess is it's because he's a canon character whose not really a canon character, and in that case, he's a bit like writing an original character, and I won't butcher him badly beyond the point of recognition like I feel I do with the other HP characters, lol.

Ah, I'm glad the dialogue rung true for you since it's something that is important to me as a writer. It's always reassuring to know I'm doing something effectively. And that line about Barty is made all the better because of you!

Thank you for always being there for my fanfiction, ♥.
[info]cacklesthewitch wrote:
4th Jun, 2009 04:02 (UTC)
I suck at reviews lately (all my writing is suffering some strange brainblock:() but I just had to tell you how much I love your Regulus!

He is that one character in the books that is sooo intriguing, and yet never once does he pop his black-haired head in to strut and prance for us. The mystery that surrounds a boy/man who would give his life and have his revenge - he needs to be brought to life and you did it so, so well.

The awkward conversation with his big brother, the gulf between them that is evident in what they say, what they don't and how Regulus overthinks something so simple as sitting on the grass with his brother feels so genuine (God, do I know how it feels to be there, trying to find the right thing to say to someone who was once your best friend) and quite heartbreaking, really.

Basically, you touched something in me (get your mind out the gutter! *she says to herself*;D). I'm so glad I broke my own no-fic-reading rule and read this:D

Oh, and by the way, I love that Sirius was trying for Jimmy Page. I've always thought he was a Zeppelin fan but for some reason people never write him as one. Go figure.
[info]duck_or_rabbit wrote:
7th Jun, 2009 03:39 (UTC)
Your sucky reviews are very wonderful, so please leave me sucky comments. Whenever.

I've no idea why I've become as attached to Regulus as I have, and if you think I gave him a respectable portrayal, that makes me ridiculously happy, since it'd be deeply chagrin of fandom if we didn't represent him well!

I think you're on the money to say Regulus was trying to find the right word for Sirius and was groping at what exactly would work. It's a universal feeling, isn't it? That hopelessness that comes from not understanding, and you're too kind to mention that I may have gotten a bit of that done properly here.

Touching you is what I wanted to accomplish! So, thank you for letting me cop a feel. And you can bring that icon around whenever you'd like. It's lovely, and the journal is always open. (It rather matches the mental image I have of Jimmy Page!Sirius! I think Zep suits him too, and thanks for the back up, :D)
[info]hrymfaxe wrote:
7th Jun, 2009 19:55 (UTC)
So, on my slow, yet ever so enjoyable journey through the entries at [info]fandomfusion I'm finally at yours. ♥

I love how real everything feels and how overly conscious Regulus is about his surroundings and every little movement of Sirius'. Overly analytical, is probably a better description for how it reads to me, and it feels just right that he should be like that in this tense and uncomfortable situation, where he has so much hope in the outcome and so much fear that he will not see that happen. My heart aches for him...

I love how you have made the difficulty of their communication so real, both in how much trouble it took to just send the letter and in how they constantly misunderstand each other and are unable to give what the other wants. And this one broke me:

“No, you didn’t.” I correct him. “I included a charm for you, an encryption charm, and I wrote you the code in the first few letters. If you used the charm, the messages would be invisibly sent from you to me at a common pickup box at a MOMP location, then I’d get a signal at Grimmauld that post from you had arrived. I wrote the charm it this summer. I picked it up from Father’s charmineering guides.”

Sirius, you wanker!

Also, so much love for the last line and for you and your Regulus:

And then I see it, there on the grubby grass and shriveled leaves, are my wasted, partially chewed Black Balls.

Thank you so much for bringing the Black brothers to the Ides. ♥
[info]duck_or_rabbit wrote:
24th Jul, 2009 08:06 (UTC)
Hi! ::says it in her best Harry!Fexlix Felicis impression::

How did I out of 6 billion people in the world get so lucky as to have you choose me as your friend?

Overly analytical, is probably a better description for how it reads to me

Regulus strikes me as a characters who would wonder constantly if he'd said the appropriate thing, then ask if he said the appropriate thing, then ask if it was appropriate to ask. ad infinitum. So your word analytical is one I like being applied to him very much.

You and me have both agreed in the past what makes secondary characters in any canon the most compelling to write is that their stories are the most unresolved. (And I wondered for an age -- and still do -- what to call a Wizard engineer.) You said that Sirius and Regulus not giving each other what they want or need is what brought you to a breaking point, and I'm thrilled you got 1) a sense of that from what I've written and 2) that I've touch on something that you can identify with despite these characters existing in this era at the very periphery of anything that's in the text.

I'll admit that the Black Balls were not a device laid out in the fic's original plan, but once I got to the candy bit I knew sticky candy would most likely be stickable in Regulus' throat and by the end knew what they needed to be named. Thank you for liking that as a metaphor.

I realize that this comment signifies the first time I've talked to you in almost two months, and I hope you are doing well, :P.
Thank you for your lovely review, yet again!

Edited at 2009-07-24 08:07 (UTC)
[info]zia_montrose wrote:
9th Jun, 2009 14:39 (UTC)
This is a moving piece. Once again you’ve made me feel achingly sympathetic toward Regulus.

I can so believe that Regulus would be jealous of James. And that Sirius would scorn Regulus for remaining loyal to their family. It’s just painful to watch this severing, where Sirius’s ‘clean break’ means copping an attitude and not sparing a look back, while Regulus still wants his affection and attention. In the beginning, it seems like Sirius is just coolly immune (and a bit of a prick, really), but then it becomes apparent that he actually does care for his brother… and that ups the emotional ante at the end because you want them to find a way to reconcile their differences, to stop hurting each other.

I love the way you’ve shown Regulus holding the gift tighter and tighter. And am I interpreting your title and ending at all correctly to feel like Regulus feels pretty much emasculated by the end? As an aside, my thoughts flashed to two dogs as I read this, the weaker one rolling over sort of shamefully to show its belly to submit to the alpha who just sniffs it disdainfully and walks away. It also put me in mind of the time Sirius tells Harry (disappointedly) that he's not as much like his father as he thought.

These lines punched me as I read:
From his tone of voice, I can tell he’s enjoying annoying me, formulating a fresh confrontation…

Folded that precise way I like it…I’m half sick he’ll pick a fight over my family crest cufflinks if he sees.

He’s impossible to contradict.

He’s aware I’m a loner, but it also infuriates him to know I’ll wander around alone, hanging around for him.

I want to throw James back in his face.

Yes, it’s exactly like Quidditch, and I’ve come to ask you to play with us.

“Don’t sulk”, he laughs, not for me, but to soften his own hardening mood.

“Don’t do that.” He sounds worried. “You’ll vomit.” And tender.


…and all the lines where Regulus becomes protective of the gift…

I was also impressed by the vividness of your 1st person account. Lots of little mental pictures and imagery along the way. As with the last one I read, it thrills me to see someone writing the Black brothers like this!
[info]duck_or_rabbit wrote:
12th Jun, 2009 00:49 (UTC)
Oh, I'm extremely moved by your comment, thank you. It's just brilliant; wow.

Gosh, my first person was successful? Thank you in spades because I'm never sure if I get it right. Filling the moment with descriptions but keeping the narrator's thoughts realistic, like not picking up everything and only what resonates with them in a believable way, is tricky. Thank you so much for the reassurance it went right here.

I can so believe that Regulus would be jealous of James. And that Sirius would scorn Regulus for remaining loyal to their family.

Bingo, yes, I'm pleased that through the combination of Regulus' introspection and Sirius' dialogue this held together because it's exactly what I wanted. Honestly, it's at the core of the story. There's a lasting force between the two brothers (brothers which I'm thrilled you believe I've portrayed well) and that force may possibly be familial love, though neither are beyond their years to call it such a thing. And coping is the ideal word to describe Sirius' reaction to leaving Grimmauld for good. He closed a book and uninvolved himself deliberately, but this that point to “Don’t do that.” He sounds worried. “You’ll vomit.” And tender. is where Regulus notices Sirius stumble, and he may be as unprepared for this sincerity from his brother as he was for the rejection he experienced when Sirius left.

but then it becomes apparent that he actually does care for his brother… and that ups the emotional ante at the end because you want them to find a way to reconcile their differences, to stop hurting each other.

There's an interesting second part to this story that I'm not sure I'll finish or not in which Sirius explains, looking back, moving in with James worked, but only for a while. Being enfolded into the Potter's bosom didn't work out and he moves beyond them as well. Is it any wonder Regulus' owls sent to the Potters never made it to him? Perhaps there's a decent reason for Sirius' restricted communication after all? Well see if I get to writing it....

As an aside, my thoughts flashed to two dogs as I read this, the weaker one rolling over sort of shamefully to show its belly to submit to the alpha who just sniffs it disdainfully and walks away.

Growing up, becoming individuals, creating self-love, doing without fraternal love are the themes I attempted to show here (although deceptively hard to write I realized as I went along) and this observation of yours in an interesting one because it shows how things turn out between two people who are trying to think of themselves as equals but one is always compromised (or they choose to remain in that submissive position because it's where they've learned they're most comfortable). Both the boys are experiencing the weighty burdens of youth and what I hate about their dynamic is that they couldn't emulate one another's better bits and through each other discover the strength they need to carry those burdens. Like you say, by this point, Sirius and Regulus both identify with their parents in very different ways and what's irreconcilable between parent and child may be also doomed between brothers.

I've sufficiently rambled long enough at you, and all I can say is thank you for your rich, thought provoking feedback. I respect you immensely for your ability to interpret fiction, and a million thanks for putting up with my lopsided attempts to respond to you properly, ♥.

Edited at 2009-06-12 00:54 (UTC)
[info]remeciel wrote:
10th Jun, 2009 17:23 (UTC)
*inserts your fic into JKR's novel* this was missing in the books. Knowing more about Regulus's intentions. Why he chose this side rather than the other, and why he decided to change his mind. I've deeply regretted she forgot about this very character - so thank you for writing more about him. :)
[info]duck_or_rabbit wrote:
22nd Jun, 2009 13:54 (UTC)
::thanks you for the canon insertion::

A MILLION apologies for a massively late reply to your wonderful comment. I'd been in-and-out of another work project the last week and a half, and that always effects my time on lj. But when I got this, it was really touching and it helped me through my non-HP day undoubtedly.

It was a marginal relief Regulus received the attention he did in DH in the chapter, Kreacher's Tale. He was another wasted Black, I agree, but at least some proof of his instincts to destroy the Horcuxes appeared in that final book. Regulus never says a word in the books, but I love the reception fandom gives him, :D.

When I get a chance to write more, I hope to write more of Regulus, and I promise to not leave your reply unresponded to for so long if you choose to leave feedback.

Thank you so much, dear, ♥.
[info]remeciel wrote:
22nd Jun, 2009 19:58 (UTC)
Oh, don't worry! *hugs* I'm glad this notification wasn't lost or something like that. Lj can be weird like this sometimes...

Anyway, I really hope to hear more of Regulus in your fics. He's far more an interesting character than Harry. *g*
[info]gilpin25 wrote:
13th Jun, 2009 22:11 (UTC)
It's great to see little nipper again.

What I particularly like about your Regulus is that he really feels and reads fourteen, uncertainly poised somewhere between boy and man and not quite comfortably either at any one time. He's a lovely mass of awkward contradictions both inside and out: the cufflinks versus the childish use of Mummy (I can never imagine Sirius saying that, lol), the smoking versus the fact that he's waited two hours in desperate need for his older brother to stroll noisily and casually up. And that older brother's been side-tracked playing Frisbee...

I was going to judge Sirius fairly harshly for the letters, but I've read your comment above that there's more to it than there appears. But then that's all part of the misunderstanding of motives and actions between them. It is somehow typical of Sirius to remember to buy the sweets, which isn't nearly enough of a gesture - though what Regulus wants he couldn't give him, anyway - and yet reveal through them the fact that he does care and hurt himself, however much he thinks he's walked away from this.

I very much liked:

I’m caught by all the disappointment I ended up with after he left for James, showing me I no longer suited him.

As I very much doubt that Sirius sees it as a simple exchange like that, and is probably highly exasperated that Regulus sees it in those terms and misses the bigger picture? Expect that probably is the picture that matters most at fourteen.

And also:

“You’re not, you know, making up for my faults around home, are you?”
I tense, slightly bewildered by his question. “No. I’m . . . . What do you mean?”


Is positively chilling, especially as it makes me wonder all sorts of things. As does the lengths Regulus has to go to to send the letters in the first place - and he's much more like a clever and cunning young man there than a hurt and vulnerable young boy.

Immensely thought-provoking and thoughtfully done, as always! Yay for little nipper and I hope there'll be much more.:D
[info]duck_or_rabbit wrote:
24th Jul, 2009 07:39 (UTC)
So, one hundred years after your comment, I'm leaving my thanks. Could I be more ungrateful? Truly, I am sorry because your thoughts always mean so much to me. Don't take this the wrong way because wisdom is timeless, but your insights are consistently mature compared to what's often offered as lj reviews, and I hate to do anything less than worship you for giving me your thoughts. On that theme generally I sometimes have a difficult time accepting praise for fiction I've written because I'm in denial that anything I wrote would actually be enjoyed by the reader. I know that's common amongst all creative folks, but because nice things sometimes make me painfully shy, it also can make me seem overly cold. So sorry for not having got to this sooner...

All that said, onward.

But then that's all part of the misunderstanding of motives and actions between them. + he does care and hurt himself, however much he thinks he's walked away from this.

It's marvelous you say this because how we react towards those that mean the most is frequently based on not having all the information, or at least what's simply relevant enough for us to conduct productive and non-defensive interactions with one another. Being a teenager (as I can remember) is an incredibly selfish, exciting time, and the 'newness' of Sirius being on his own is something I want to be exploring in the background of this story. And what's interesting is that the differences that have built up between Sirius and Regulus may be just too deep to heal despite them both being so young of life.

As does the lengths Regulus has to go to to send the letters in the first place - and he's much more like a clever and cunning young man there than a hurt and vulnerable young boy.

Oh, congratulations, young Regulus! [info]gilpin25 sees right what you're up to! Now that the canon is complete and every character's motif is closed for better or worse as far as JKR is concerned, us fans are like Senior Detectives deciding what will be our ultimate impression of who we've latched onto. Before Book 6 era, the old school interpretation of Regulus was that he was a spoiled Victorianish Blue Blood Son, and that may not be too far off, but now lump him together with Harry's Horcrux Destruction, so what are we to do with him? You and me both think that he's more than a vulnerable boy.


Immensely thought-provoking and thoughtfully done, as always! Yay for little nipper and I hope there'll be much more.:D


Thank you, I really appreciate it because although the heyday of Harry Potter fandom seems as if it were a lifetime ago, and now it's pretty much confined to ones own house instead of a global discussion, I still have ideas waiting to be written, and I don't need to tell you that I'm happy to use fanfiction writing as a personal benefit, as a way to get better at writing, even if it's a round about way.

Thank you, Gilpin. It's very UnBritish to say so, but you are so wonderful and make me feel wonderful and are just a Harry Potter fandom treasure, ♥.

[info]gilpin25 wrote:
24th Jul, 2009 21:21 (UTC)
Remind me to re-read this next time the writing/fandom/RL world (is my order of importance telling?;)) is especially crap. It's totally undeserved but it means a great deal. ♥

And some of us are still trying to read fics at [info]fandomfusion, so no worries ever about review replies. I'm so behind these days the White Rabbit's overtaken me, lol.
( 29 players — Play the language game )